Actually, in hindsight, I'm not sure anything was actually wrong with the site. It appears that the user_login-out plugin was/is the issue. It does not work. Activating the plugin, and trying to use the login window (or link) it presents, consistently leads to the error page previously mentioned. It doesn't matter which option I choose. Anyway, at some point, I will post a new topic and try to figure it out, because I'm a little nervous about sending anyone to admin.php to login.