Thanks, I tried that as you suggested with no luck. The one thing that I find funny, is that the link changes when going to page 2.
If I manually type the search into the browser bar:
http://www.moonshadeaux.com/Fish_Guide/page/search/crate+exclusive
Returns results correctly, but when I click to go to page two, the link looks like this:
http://www.moonshadeaux.com/Fish_Guide/page/search/"crate+exclusive"/2 (actual appearance in my address bar)
(When I paste into the forum, looks like this: http://www.moonshadeaux.com/Fish_Guide/page/search/%22crate+exclusive%22/2)
This returns "no matches found".
I probably won't have time to do a clean install until next week some time.